If I told you that I knew a family in which both spouses graduated from Law School 12 years ago and that they still owed $60,000 in student loans (the original debt was about $135,000), would you think they were rich?
If I told you that the husband of this hypothetical family drives a 2002 Ford Explorer and that the wife drives a 2007 Saturn Outlook (and that neither car has leather seats), would you think they were rich?
If I told you that many of their neighbors are teachers and principals, would you think they were rich?
If I told you that their kitchen countertops are Formica, not granite, would you think they were rich?
If I told you that this family made almost exactly $250,000 in 2008, would you change your mind?
Before this hypothetical family can even go to work, they pay $20,000 in child care expense. They have a cleaning lady and pay her $2,000 per year. Those student loans that they still have - they pay about $10,000 per year on them. You might say that that still leaves this family with $218,000 and you would be right. In 2008, this family paid almost $80,000 in federal, state and local taxes. Yes, I said $80,000. Obama says that this hypothetical family pay more because they are wealthy. How can he not get it? He said that he and his wife "only recently" paid off their student loans. This hypothetical family tries to save money for retirement since Social Security won't be there for them and they don't have pensions. They also try to save for the college education of their 3 children since they expect the colleges to tell them that they can afford to pay full price. They are trying hard to do the responsible things and yet, somehow, they are told that it isn't enough - they are rich so they can pay more.
I'm not going to lie. They live a comfortable life. They stressed about the rising price of gas last summer but were able to reduce consumption elsewhere to make it work. Every year they take a vacation - to the beach or somewhere - but they usually drive because it's cheaper. They eat out at a restuarant like Applebee's or Red Robin a couple times each month. They built a nice house in exurbia in 2004 but didn't splurge on granite countertops. They still have plenty of hand-me down furniture in their house. And, there are still a few bedrooms that haven't yet been painted. Does it sounds like they live an extravangant life - a life that a wealthy family would live?
Yet, somehow, Obama thinks this hypothetical family is rich. He wants to repeal the Bush Tax Cuts on the "wealthiest Americans" which he defines as families making over $250,000 per year. That's this hypothetical family. Well, President Obama, the wife may decide to have her own private Tea Party and quit her job. If she quits her job, the Treasury would get about $15,000 from them in federal income taxes rather than the $48,000 that they paid in 2008 (not counting the Medicare and Social Security taxes that she won't be paying). If this hypothetical family only made $125,000 per year, the interest on their student loans would be deductible, they wouldn't get whacked with the Alternative Minimum Tax, they could clean their own house, she could watch their kids, etc. Oh, sure, this hypothetical family might have to make a few cutbacks but they could make it work. So, Obama, if you think you are going to get a lot more money by taxing the Tea, plenty of that Tea might get thrown into the Allegheny River. President Obama, re-think your tax position and, please, stop calling me rich.
Monday, February 23, 2009
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Hi 'Mom',
ReplyDeleteI just got caught up on your recent blogs, and this is your best one yet!
These policies that Obama is planning are going to place a huge burden on people like you and me, and reward those who bought houses they could not afford and who can't seem to make it without a government handout of some kind.
My retirement plans have gone up in smoke (along with many others in my age group), and it is small comfort to know that by working a few years longer, someone else will be able to live irresponsibly and get bailed out by our government (using MY hard-earned money) when they get into trouble!