Tuesday, March 3, 2009

Stop Saying I Can Afford It!

Recently, I have heard both Rush and Hannity talk about the impending tax increases that Obama is proposing. In these monologues about the tax increases, I have heard them both say "I can afford it". Hey, guys, please stop saying that!! When you say that, you are letting the Democrats define the debate. It has nothing to do with whether a person can or can't afford the tax increases. There is a limit on how much any person thinks another person should pay in taxes as a percentage of their income. What is that amount? Is it one-third? Is it one-half? That is the discussion we need to have. Since 40% of people who file tax returns don't even pay taxes, when they are asked whether taxes should be increased on the rich, they will say yes. However, if asked, these same people will tell you that no person should pay more than X% of their income to the government. What is that amount? Hasn't that amount been determined in a focus group?? Let's talk about that percentage. I am guessing that percentage is around one-third and we're already there - before Obama increases taxes.

Rush and Hannity - Please redefine the debate. Small business people aren't the only people who make $250,000 plus. A lot of people who make $250,000 are like me, two income professionals with hefty student loans and day care expenses. When you're like me, you stimulate the economy every day by paying a babysitter and a cleaning lady and all kinds of other people who make your life more convenient. On the other extreme of the income spectrum, you have people like Bill Gates. The innovation of Bill Gates employs countless people and has made lots of people millionaires. Although I think he spends his money on some silly causes, it is his money to spend how he wants and I am glad that he had the courage to do what he has done. Let's not demonize people like my husband and me or people like Bill Gates. And let's ask the right questions - the question isn't whether we can afford to pay more; the question is how much of any a person's income should he or she be required to contribute to the government.

In my next post, I am going to write about the fact that in order for the Republicans to win the current debate, they actually need to stop talking about tax policy and start talking about spending policy. The discussion about spending policy is a winner - especially today with a Democratic Congress and President.

Sunday, March 1, 2009

When Is Enough Enough??

My Grandpa is in his 80s, in the late stages of Altzheimer's and has blood clots in his legs causing them to swell. When the blod clots came up this past week, the nurse and doctor immediately recommended that he be taken to the hospital and a stent put in. Well, when my mom balked, she was told by a nurse that the failure to pursue this course of action would result in gangrene and amputation. What???

Okay, now for some background. In December, 2006, my grandmother passed away suddenly. Before that time, my grandfather still lived at home, drove his car and worked a couple days a week cleaning parking lots. He knew all of his children and many of his grandchildren. After my grandmother passed, it became apparent to my mom and her siblings that my grandfather could not live alone. After several months and much time researching nursing homes and considering finances, they found a nursing home for him. It has been heartbreaking for his kids to watch him go downhill in the past 2 years. At this point, he rarely recognizes any of his children.

At various points during the funeral events and during the subsequent months, my grandfather would say things like "It should have been me", "Can I go with her?" and "I just want to be with Anne" to anyone who would listen. He also told my mom and probably others "I'm not afraid to die". Because of his condition and the fact that he made these statements, the siblings decided, upon consultation with his doctor, to cease all medications for things like cholesterol. They continued with vitamins and because of things that happened in the nursing home, they added anti-depressant/anxiety medication to make him more comfortable. Altzheimer's is a terrible disease and death by Altzheimer's is extremely ugly. Based on that, it seemed crazy and maybe even cruel to continue to control his cholesterol to prevent a heart attack just so he could die from Altzheimer's.

Last summer, for various reasons, he was moved from one nursing home to another. This was an extremely traumatic move for my grandfather. It caused him to be agitated and I think he may have even had one violent incident.

That brings us to the events of this week. When the blood clot in the leg came on suddenly, the medical professionals viewed it as "very treatable" with a stent. They didn't consider the emotional impact of a transfer to a hospital. All my grandfather has left are his emotions and sense of comfort in where he is. So when they recommended the treatment to my mom, I guess they were shocked that she didn't immediately say "do it". After further research, it was determined that the gangrene and amputation risk is extremely remote.

Why didn't the medical professional consider all of the risks? I mean, when you move a patient in his condition to a hospital, there is a very real risk that the trauma will cause his immediate death, meaning that his last few hours were agonizing for him. My mom and her siblings don't want to hasten his death but they don't want to needlessly prolong it. More than anything, they want him to be treated with dignity and respect-after all, that is how everyone should be treated, regardless of their condition. Now Hospice is involved and is monitoring his pain level. His life is in the hands of God. Of course, there is at least one person at the nursing home who thinks my mom and her siblings made the wrong decision and won't speak to my mother. She doesn't know that my mom has doubts and has cried over this decision. It wasn't easy.

Every week at church, we pray for all life from Conception until Natural Death. It is my sincere belief that the decision my grandfather's children have made for him is a compassionate one and treats him with dignity. The treatment that the medical professionals recommended did not. The medical professionals only considered his physical being alive and didn't even consider the human element. So when my grandfather succumbs to Natural Death, his Soul will leave his body, we will all weep and think about his life. Until then, we all want him to be comfortable, emotionally and physically.